The Blue Eagle Tavern is a countryside local on Italy Hill Road near Branchport, serving the hills above Keuka Lake's west branch with hearty food, cold drinks and genuine back-road hospitality. It is the kind of rural tavern that anchors its community: familiar faces, generous plates and live music nights that pull neighbors in from miles around. Keuka hill country at its most welcoming, and worth the winding drive up Italy Hill from Branchport every time.